Team Select:
| Year | Team Name | Record | Rank | Results | |
| 1887 | New York Metropolitans | 44-89 | 7th | AA | |
| 1886 | New York Metropolitans | 53-82 | 7th | AA | |
| 1885 | New York Metropolitans | 44-64 | 7th | AA | |
| 1884 | New York Metropolitans | 75-32 | 1st | AA | AACS |
| 1883 | New York Metropolitans | 54-42 | 4th | AA | |