Team Select:
| Year | Team Name | Record | Rank | Results | |
| 1875 | New York Mutuals | 30-38 | 6th | NA | |
| 1874 | New York Mutuals | 42-23 | 2nd | NA | |
| 1873 | New York Mutuals | 29-24 | 4th | NA | |
| 1872 | New York Mutuals | 34-20 | 3rd | NA | |
| 1871 | New York Mutuals | 16-17 | 5th | NA | |
| Year | Team Name | Record | Rank | Results | |
| 1875 | New York Mutuals | 30-38 | 6th | NA | |
| 1874 | New York Mutuals | 42-23 | 2nd | NA | |
| 1873 | New York Mutuals | 29-24 | 4th | NA | |
| 1872 | New York Mutuals | 34-20 | 3rd | NA | |
| 1871 | New York Mutuals | 16-17 | 5th | NA | |